This and the oxymel are my contributions (along with a sauce for meat) to a potluck next week. The Storvik Early Northern European Adhocracy is celebrating our one-year anniversary with a dinner. I got drinks and dessert.
"Carolingian Foodways" (Compleat Anachronist 156) contains several hypothetical or conjectural recipes. One of them is baked apples or pears. One of the author's sources - it may have been Benedictine rules - mentioned a basket of fresh fruit as a good ending to a meal. The author suggests that monks were encouraged to eat foods plain and raw, and that non-monks might have done different things with their fruit. Certainly the Romans stewed enough apricots and such.
But baked apples without cinnamon (!) seemed so... sad. Now I suppose I could go and do apples with honey and cream, maybe some raisins, and that actually sounds pretty good now that I type it out. But I got it into my head to do a custard. There's a Carolingian copy of Apicius, see, and he's got a simple custard recipe. Milk, eggs, honey. It's finished with white pepper, but that's easy enough to omit. (This redaction contains cumin, too, but it's the only one to do so. Cumin? I know the Romans liked to mix their sweets and savories, but I don't think I've ever seen cumin in a dessert. Those tend to be honey, eggs, almonds, and milk or white bread-based.) This recipe (which is copied with volumetric units over here) calls for half milk, half cream, which seems sensible. Last night, though, I made this recipe, because it only needed milk, and that's what I had in the house. Inspired by this, I cored an apple (a Honeycrisp that was around) and plunked it in a corner of the baking pan.
Pro Tip: Add the honey to the milk in a thin stream, whisking the entire time. No problem with honey lumping in the bottom of the bowl.
It wasn't bad, but it didn't quite hang together. The apple got soft-ish but was still pretty firm after 40min at 300 F. The custard is, to a modern palate, very plain. There's no vanilla, no cinnamon, just creamy, sweet, and slightly eggy. Eating it with the apple should have given some additional flavor, but... I don't know. I had the impression I was eating custard and an apple, not a dish "baked apple in custard." Possibly the apple should be softer?
Or I am just over-reaching. Maybe I should do baked fruits or custard.